Spring singleton and singleton design pattern vs Ext JS 4 singleton and JavaScript Singleton

I discussed "Implementing Singleton object in JavaScript" and "Implementing Singleton pattern in Java and PHP shows different "static" modifers between Java and PHP". Today, I am going to compare the similarity between difference between Java Singleton pattern and Spring singleton and difference between Javascript singleton pattern and Ext JS 4 singleton object.

As described in Spring document, Spring's concept of a singleton bean is different from the Singleton patter, which could be called GoF (Gang of Four) Singleton. As discussed in my post "Java Class loader and static variable and JVM memory management", the GoF Singleton implements one and only one instance of a particular class will ever be created per ClassLoader. Meanwhile, the singleton object defined in Spring framework is single/unique object managed in Spring container. So, Spring singleton needs to be carefully used in multithread environment. Normally, we should use Spring prototype instead of singleton as service that will be requested by multi threads.

Now let's look at Ext JS 4 singleton. I will say it has similar implementation as Spring singleton. That is, Ext JS 4 develops a container to hold all Ext JS 4 class/object. JavaScript's multi-task programming is not popular yet. However, how about testing this through two tab in same browser?

This discussion reveals how Ext JS 4 implements singleton. It is pretty similar as the way Spring does. In Ext JS 4, a singleton is an object instead a class. It's not the same with GoF Singleton just like Spring singleton is not same with GoF Singleton. I think this is an interesting investigation.

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3920689/plain-old-singleton-or-spring-singleton-bean http://www.bleext.com/blog/configurations-statics-and-singleton-in-ext-js-4/ http://www.sencha.com/forum/showthread.php?128646-Singleton-vs-class-with-all-static-members